Chatham courthouse. (Photo by Paul Pedro)
Windsor

Convicted son testifies at mother's Tilbury murder trial

The man convicted of murdering his roommate in Tilbury almost three years ago has testified at his mother's first degree murder trial.

David Trealout testified in Chatham Superior Court on Tuesday that he killed Henry Neudorf on January 11, 2024 because Neudorf was drunk all the time, made sexual advances towards his mother, Kim Price, and angered him.

Trealout said something triggered him the night of the murder, adding that all four people living at the rental house north of Tilbury and Price's ex-boyfriend, Darrin Noland, who was visiting, planned how to kill Neudorf.

Trealout said it was his idea to grab the heavy cast iron frying pan and strike Neudorf several times in the back of the skull. However, he added that it was Price who told him when to enter from the garage and ambush Neudorf.

Trealout testified Neudorf wasn't dead until Price suffocated him with plastic bags.

He also told the court that all five people at the house the night of the murder disposed of the body in a ditch in Dover Township and it was his idea to hide evidence, such as the frying pan, gloves, and cleaning materials, throughout Leamington.

Trealout also noted he directed the others to clean up the murder scene.

He added that everyone, except Noland, who had already been dropped off at home, celebrated Neudorf's murder because they were so mad at him and it seemed like the right thing to do at the time.

He concluded his testimony for the day by saying all four roommates decided to keep the murder a secret and stayed at a Kingsville area motel because they were afraid of getting caught.

However, Trealout noted something was not right when he woke up the morning after the murder and saw Price talking to a male friend outside, wasn't allowed in the vehicle, and wasn't going to Windsor as planned, heading towards Leamington instead.

Earlier, one of Neudorf's roommates testified that everybody in the house was terrified of Trealout before and after Neudorf was murdered.

A forgetful and often confused Tammy Michaud told the court Trealout is dangerous and could easily snap and lose control at any time.

Michaud said Price feared Trealout and had trouble controlling him because he was a ticking time bomb.

She added everyone told Trealout not to kill Neudorf, but he didn't want to listen.

Michaud also said Trealout was constantly monitoring the others after the murder to prevent them from calling police and never left anyone alone.

She testified Trealout also threatened to kill a female police officer and take her cruiser after the murder.

Michaud also told the court that Tealout threatened to kill Price's cats if she went to the police.

She concluded her testimony by saying that Price later encouraged her to be truthful and not leave anything out with police.

The trial continues on Wednesday with the cross examination of Trealout by the defence.

Trealout was sentenced in September to life in prison with no chance of parole for 15 years after pleading guilty to second degree murder in September 2025.

Read More Local Stories

A hockey puck on an ice surface. © Can Stock Photo / vencavolrab

Scoreboard, Nov 17

The Montreal Canadiens lost their second straight game, falling 3-1 to the New York Rangers at Madison Square Garden Monday night.

Lambton Public Health building (Photo by: Lindsay Newman/ Blackburn Media)

LPH searching for dog following bite incident

The dog is described as a medium-sized black German shepherd with blue eyes, and was being walked by an individual described as a man between 40 and 50 years of age, wearing a black jacket and blue jeans.